In this article, Liel Liebovitz discusses how many atheists appear to be committed to their denial of the existence of God with the same sort of devotion as Christian fundamentalists. He briefly compares atheism in Britain with the same in America, and notes that in America there is a dogmatism that is absent in the old country.
Any Christian who has ever engaged an atheist of the Dawkins-Harris-Dennett-Hitchens sort is quite familiar with the religious dogmatism held by many atheists. Pre-Dawkins atheism used to be held quietly, unobtrusively, and matter-of-factly. Today, the "new atheism" is set about on eliminating religious belief. Today's atheists know that God doesn't exist--but they hate him all the same. They would strenuously deny this inconsistency of course, but given the rhetoric found in the writings of the new atheists, it seems to be a relatively easy case to make against them.
Here is a portion of Liebovitz's article:
You know you’re living in troubled times when even atheists feel the need to invoke God’s name to get their point across.
That’s
just what American Atheists, the nation’s largest organization of
non-believers, did last week when it put up two billboards — one in a
predominantly ultra-Orthodox neighborhood in Brooklyn, N.Y., and the
other near a mosque in Paterson, N.J. — emblazoned with the Lord’s name
in Hebrew and Arabic, respectively. “You know it’s a myth,” reads the
sign. “And you have a choice.” The Hebrew billboard featured the letters
YHWH, God’s explicit name and a sacred term that Jews refrain from
using.
As could be expected of our impassioned moment, the
billboard’s intended audience was insulted on cue and reacted
resolutely: The Brooklyn landlord whose building was slated to display
the sign refused to erect it, leading American Atheists president David
Silverman to cry persecution. “It was very disappointing to me because I
was raised Jewish,” he said in an interview on Wednesday. “They’ve been
the victims of religious bigotry, and now they’re the purveyors.”
It’s
a compelling storyline, but it tells us more about the nonbelievers
than it does about the pious communities they have offended. To study
l’affaire billboard is to understand a peculiar reality of this godly
country: In America, even the atheists are deeply religious.
“I want again to breathe your free Air. I expect it will mend my Constitution and confirm my principles. I have indeed as good an Atmosphere at home as the Climate will allow: but have nothing to brag of as to the State and Liberty of my Country. . . . So I [leave you] to pity me and pray for Liberty of Conscience [to revive among us.]”
James Madison to William Bradford of Pennsylvania, January 24, 1774
James Madison to William Bradford of Pennsylvania, January 24, 1774
Monday, March 12, 2012
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment